This story is a follow-up to ‘I want my hat back’. The tale takes a twist on honesty with a small fish who is very honest about being dishonest. After stealing a hat from another fish, we see the thoughts of the fishy thief. The thief is seen by a crab and, although the crab agrees not to tell anyone where the fish is going, the crab is clearly not to be trusted. Ultimately, the fish is discovered (and probably eaten). This is a great story with which to discuss honesty with younger children… particularly whether the crab was right to break his agreement with a thief!